Great River, Islip, Suffolk County, New York

Built in 1887, for W. Bayard Cutting (1850-1912) and his wife, Olivia Peyton Murray (1855-1949). Two years previously, Bayard and his brother, Fulton, bought the 931-acre estate on the South Shore of Long Island from tobacco heir and racing enthusiast, George Lyndes Lorillard. Fulton took up in Lorillard's old house and Bayard commissioned Charles C. Haight (1841-1917) to design his new home on his half....

This house is best associated with...

William Bayard Cutting

W. Bayard Cutting of New York City & "Westbrook" Long Island


Olivia Peyton (Murray) Cutting

Mrs Olivia Peyton (Murray) Cutting


Olivia Murray (Cutting) James

Mrs Olivia (Cutting) James


Completed in the Tudor-Revival style, it contains 68-rooms, stained glass-windows and exquisitely carved fireplaces salvaged along with the paneling in the main hall from old English houses. Westbrook was particularly notable for the Scottish heather with which the gatehouse was thatched - literally imported from Scotland; and, in 1895 the Cutting brothers laid out what is said to be the first private golf course in America - though Fairlawn in Lake Forest has a pretty good claim too. The beautiful grounds were landscaped by none other than Frederick Law Olmsted and the views from the house overlook the Connetquot River from across the lawns. Bayard and Olivia divided their time between here and their brownstone in New York at 24 East 72nd Street.

After Bayard died, his widow lived here quietly with their divorced daughter, Mrs James. In 1936, they gave 200-acres to create an Arboretum and in 1952 Mrs James gifted the whole park with a $1 million endowment to establish the "Bayard Cutting Arboretum State Park" with the house acting as a restaurant, gift shop, self-guided museum, and offices. 


Contributed by Mark Meredith on 14/11/2019 and last updated on 11/10/2021.
Image Courtesy of Wikimapia; The Thing Done Handsomely (2014), from the late great John Foreman; 


Be the first to connect to this house. Connect to record your link to this house. or just to show you love it! Connect to Westbrook →